Soft breath, balanced body

Slowing the breath down brings the body into balance. It calms the nervous system, steadies the rhythm of the heart and gently moves the organs.

Notice your breath on a busy day. Often it sits high in the chest: short, quick, a little held. The shoulders lift a bit with every in-breath. Nothing is wrong, exactly. It is the breath of a body getting ready for something.

Now let it drop. The belly rises gently as you breathe in, the out-breath grows longer, and nothing is pushed. Often, within a minute, something settles.

That small change reaches further than it seems: into the nervous system, the rhythm of the heart, blood pressure, and the organs under the diaphragm. Here, slowing down and yielding bring the whole system into better balance.

The effect on the heart

The heart doesn’t beat like a metronome. It speeds up slightly with every in-breath and slows with every out-breath. The slowing comes from the vagus nerve, the main nerve of the body’s rest-and-recover system.

This variation, called heart rate variability, is the mark of a heart that adapts easily: quick to rise when needed, quick to settle afterwards. People whose heart rhythm varies less go on to have more heart problems in the following years (Tsuji et al., 1996).

Slow breathing makes the swing larger. A meta-analysis of 223 studies found that voluntary slow breathing raises heart rate variability during practice, right after a session, and after programmes of several sessions (Laborde et al., 2022). The effect peaks at around six breaths a minute, about five seconds in and five seconds out, where the rhythms of breath, heart and blood pressure fall into step.

A study in Italy found the same rhythm in prayer. When people recited the rosary in Latin, or a yoga mantra, their breathing slowed by itself to almost exactly six breaths a minute, and their heart rhythms and baroreflex followed (Bernardi et al., 2001).

Reviewing the physiology, Russo and colleagues conclude that slow breathing “appears capable of achieving optimal sympathovagal balance, and enhancing autonomic reactivity to physical and mental stress”: a nervous system in balance, that rises to a challenge and settles again.

The effect on blood pressure

At around six breaths a minute, the baroreflex also becomes more sensitive (Russo et al., 2017). The baroreflex is the body’s automatic blood-pressure control: sensors in the large arteries notice a rise or a drop and adjust the heartbeat within seconds, which is why you don’t faint every time you stand up. When it is sluggish, blood pressure swings more. After a heart attack, a weak baroreflex and a low heart rate variability each point to a higher risk of dying (La Rovere et al., 1998).

Blood pressure itself comes down too. In people with high blood pressure, a few minutes of breathing at six a minute brought it down from about 150/83 to 141/78 mm Hg (Joseph et al., 2005). With regular practice, across 17 trials, the average drop was about 5.6 mm Hg in the upper number and 3 in the lower (Chaddha et al., 2019). That is in the same range as regular endurance exercise, which lowers the upper number by around 8 mm Hg in people with high blood pressure (Cornelissen & Smart, 2013). For scale: in large trials of blood-pressure medication, every 5 mm Hg off the upper number lowered the risk of heart attack, stroke and heart failure by about 10% (Blood Pressure Lowering Treatment Trialists’ Collaboration, 2021). No study has yet followed people who practise slow breathing for years to count heart attacks, so for breathing this is a reasonable hope rather than a proven result.

The effect on the organs

When you breathe low, the diaphragm, a dome of muscle under the lungs, flattens and moves down, pressing gently on the liver, stomach and intestines. On the out-breath it rises and the pressure eases. Physiologists measure it as pressure and blood flow.

With each quiet diaphragmatic breath, about 50 to 75 ml of blood is squeezed out of the veins of the abdomen and drawn back in, with the liver emptying first (Aliverti et al., 2009). The researchers call it the abdominal circulatory pump. The heart pushes blood out with force, but the way back through the veins gets little push of its own; it relies on help from the muscles around the veins. The breath is one of those helpers: each low breath squeezes the abdominal veins like a sponge and sends blood up toward the heart, which then refills more easily. During exercise, when breathing is deep and strong, this pump may act like a second, smaller heart (Uva et al., 2016).

Digestion can benefit as well. In a small trial in people with acid reflux, four weeks of belly-breathing training reduced the time the oesophagus spent in acid and improved quality of life; nine months later, the breathing group was using less reflux medication (Eherer et al., 2012).

Longer exhales for further effects

The longer out-breath has been tested on its own. In a 1984 experiment, students breathed at six breaths a minute with one of three patterns, then waited for, and received, painful but harmless electric shocks. Only the pattern with a quick in-breath and a slow out-breath kept them calmer both while waiting and during the shocks, both on skin conductance (a measure of stress arousal) and in how anxious they felt. An even in-and-out rhythm helped while waiting, but not once the shocks came. The authors noted that yoga masters had recommended this for many years, and that theirs appeared to be “the first controlled test of its utility” (Cappo & Holmes, 1984).

Practice: the 2:1 breath

Exhale twice as long as you inhale. A classic of yoga breath training, and close to what the 1984 experiment tested.

  1. Settle. Sit comfortably or lie on your back. One hand on your chest, one on your belly.
  2. Breathe low. Through the nose. As you breathe in, the belly hand rises; the chest hand stays almost still.
  3. Count. In for three, out for six. If that is easy, in for four, out for eight: about five breaths a minute.
  4. Keep it smooth. No holding at the top, no pushing the last air out. The out-breath just gets slower.
  5. Let go of the numbers. After a few rounds, keep only the feeling: a short, easy in-breath, a long, soft out-breath.

Two minutes is enough to feel it; ten minutes makes a good daily practice. You can also practise it in public transport, while you wait for someone, or when you’re about to have a difficult conversation.

If you feel light-headed or short of air, the counts are too long. Shorten them, or go back to normal breathing. If you have a heart or lung condition, or take medication for blood pressure, keep it gentle and talk to your doctor before practising for longer.

Keep reading

Sources

Practice

  • Nuernberger P (1981). Freedom from Stress: A Holistic Approach. Himalayan International Institute, ch. 6 (2:1 breathing).

Research

This article shares general information; it is not medical advice.