Verbal aikido
Two tense meetings, one lesson: staying soft under provocation is a skill you can train, and knowing your trigger is half of it.
A few years ago, when I was working as a consultant, I sat across the table from a man who did not want us there.
He was a senior person at our client. The project we were running was a threat to his unit, and he knew it. He couldn’t refuse to meet us, so he accepted out of politeness. Then he spent the meeting slowing us down.
He never said anything openly hostile. Everything was phrased in a correct, careful way, the kind of sentences you can’t object to. But the intent underneath was clear. He was trying to provoke us: to get a defensive answer, a sharp reply, anything he could later point to. And he stayed entirely within his rights while doing it.
I was leading the meeting, with a colleague next to me. And I did something that, at the time, felt almost too simple.
I played naive.
Going along instead of pushing back
I nodded. I went along with him a little. I asked probing questions, and I was genuinely interested in the answers. I let him say everything he had to say, and I made sure he could see that he was being heard. He was, I think, happy to finally get it all out.
And then something interesting happened: once he had said everything, there was nothing left. Nothing concrete, nothing that actually stood against the project. His objections had been energy, not substance, and energy that meets no resistance has nowhere to go.
He didn’t become our ally. He never helped us after that. But he also stopped working against us. In the world of large organizations, that is a real win.
Much later I found words for what I had done. In judo, the founder Kano Jigoro described the principle of jū, gentleness or yielding: if you resist a stronger opponent, you lose; if you adjust to his attack and move with it, he loses his balance. Aikido is built on a similar idea of blending with an attack rather than blocking it. I had never trained in either. But in that meeting, I was doing a verbal version of it. I wasn’t meeting force with force. I was stepping aside and letting it pass.
What it actually felt like
I don’t want to make this sound effortless, because it wasn’t.
That first time, it took real concentration. More than concentration, it took awareness: seeing clearly what was happening in the room, and being able to say to myself, OK, this is what it is. Let’s move forward. And then actively staying calm, moment after moment.
Over the years, in other meetings, it has become faster. Now it is more like a quick recognition of what is going on, and then a recentering. I breathe calmly. I look around the room. I take my time. I listen, really listen. And I don’t jump.
That last one is the most powerful of all: do not jump.
There is some interesting science behind the first two steps. When researchers at UCLA asked people to put a name on an emotion (simply labeling an angry face as “angry”), the brain’s alarm center, the amygdala, calmed down, while a region of the prefrontal cortex associated with regulation became more active (Lieberman et al., 2007). This is what it is turns out to be a small act of regulation in itself.
And slow breathing, under about ten breaths a minute, has been linked in a number of small studies to higher heart-rate variability, more relaxation and less anxiety and anger (Zaccaro et al., 2018). It is the same thing I feel on the mat in yoga: the exhale is where things release.
The meeting where I did take the bait
I would love to end the story there. But there is another meeting, and it taught me just as much.
On a different project, we met a very similar situation. This time it was a woman whose role was threatened by our work, and who had herself tried to solve the same problem in the past, without success. She was highly technical, very scientific.
We did everything “right.” We met her in advance, several times, to build the relationship and understand how she felt and whether she would obstruct. Those conversations were reasonable, even good: honest, scientific discussions. She didn’t vouch for us, but she didn’t say our work was wrong or had no future either.
Then came the steering committee, with the senior decision-makers in the room. We presented the full project. And she began to take it apart, point by point, with technical arguments that, I was convinced, she knew were not valid. She was too good a scientist not to know. But in that setting, in front of that audience, I couldn’t really answer them without getting into a technical fight nobody else could follow.
It felt deeply unfair. And that feeling got me.
For a few sentences, on a couple of occasions, I lost my temper. I spoke to her far too strongly, and I was rude.
The meeting was recovered and, in the end, it went fine. But afterwards my manager took me aside and told me two things. The first: that was not OK. The second: in two years of working together, it was the first time he had seen me like that, and he was actually glad to see that I had some cracks.
Looking back, I know what the calm version of me could have said. Something like: “OK, I hear you have some deep concerns about this project. Where do you think it should head from here?”
That one question would have changed the dynamic. Either she would have had to say openly, in front of her own bosses, that she wanted to kill the project, a big risk for her that I don’t believe she would have taken. Or she would have softened, become more reasonable, and we could have had a productive discussion. Instead of fighting her arguments one by one, I would have handed her the steering wheel in front of everyone, and let the room see where she actually wanted to go.
What the two meetings taught me
Put side by side, the two meetings say a few simple things.
Calm is a skill, not a personality. I wasn’t calm the first time because I’m “a calm person.” I was calm because I was paying attention, and because I kept choosing it. It got easier with practice, like everything else we train.
Know your trigger. Mine, it turns out, is unfairness, and especially bad faith dressed up as good arguments. Hostility itself, I could absorb. The sense of injustice, with an audience watching, is what broke through. Knowing that doesn’t make me immune. But it means the next time it shows up, I can recognize it faster: ah, there it is.
Stakes and audience make it harder. In a one-to-one, softness is available. In front of decision-makers, with your work on the line, the body wants to defend. That is exactly the moment the practice is for.
The realistic win is enough. Softness didn’t turn my opponent in the first meeting into a friend. It neutralized the obstruction. That is often all you need.
Be soft with your own cracks, too. My manager’s reaction taught me this one. One lapse did not undo two years of trust. Softness isn’t only how we meet other people’s hardness; it’s also how we meet our own mistakes.
Try this: the recenter
Next time you feel a meeting turning against you, try this sequence. It takes a few seconds.
- Notice and name it. Silently: This is what it is. Or name the feeling: irritation, unfairness, fear.
- Breathe slowly. One long, unhurried exhale.
- Observe the room. Look up. Who else is here? What does the room actually need?
- Take your time. Silence is allowed. Nobody needs your answer in the next half-second.
- Listen, then ask forward. Acknowledge the concern, then ask where they think things should go: “I hear you have real concerns. Where do you think we should head from here?” An open question moves the conversation from attack to direction.
- Don’t jump. If you feel the urge to fire back, that is the signal to wait.
You won’t get it right every time. I don’t. But each time you do, you learn something that no argument could teach you: the calmest person in the room is very often the one who is really in charge.
Share your thoughts
Sources
- Lieberman MD et al. (2007). Putting feelings into words: affect labeling disrupts amygdala activity in response to affective stimuli. Psychological Science, 18(5), 421–428.
- Zaccaro A et al. (2018). How breath-control can change your life: a systematic review on psycho-physiological correlates of slow breathing. Frontiers in Human Neuroscience, 12, 353.
- On judo’s principle of jū: Kano Jigoro’s “theory of gentleness” (summary on Wikipedia: Judo; primary source to add).
This is a personal essay, not professional advice. If conflicts at work are affecting your health, consider talking to a coach, HR, or a mental-health professional.